BJJ Graph

Closed Guard Top

Jun 15, 20258 min read

Closed Guard Top

bjjstatetopguard_passing

State Properties

  • State ID: S035
  • Point Value: -1 (Slight disadvantage)
  • Position Type: Defensive passing position
  • Risk Level: Medium to High
  • Energy Cost: Medium to High
  • Time Sustainability: Medium

State Description

Closed Guard Top is the position where the top player is trapped within the bottom player’s closed guard, with the bottom player’s legs wrapped around the top player’s waist and ankles locked together. This creates a defensive scenario for the top player who must work to break the guard before being able to pass. While technically a top position, Closed Guard Top is generally considered disadvantageous due to the bottom player’s superior control, submission opportunities, and sweep potential. The position serves as the starting point for guard opening sequences and requires strategic patience and technical precision to navigate successfully.

Visual Description

You are positioned on top of your opponent, kneeling or in a combat base within the tight enclosure of their closed guard, with their legs wrapped securely around your waist and ankles crossed behind your back, restricting your mobility. Your upper body is engaged in a battle for posture, often leaning slightly forward or upright, with your hands working to control their hips, break their grips, or establish your own on their collar or wrists to prevent submissions and sweeps. Your knees are typically close to their hips or slightly wider for base, striving to maintain balance while their control limits your ability to stand or move freely. This setup creates a challenging defensive position where you must focus on posture and guard breaking to escape, all while under constant threat of attacks from below, making it a high-stakes position requiring careful strategy to transition to a more advantageous state.

Key Principles

  • Maintain proper posture to prevent submissions
  • Create and maintain defensive frames
  • Control opponent’s hips to limit mobility
  • Establish effective grips to facilitate guard opening
  • Break opponent’s ankle lock to open the guard
  • Prevent opponent from establishing dominant grips
  • Manage energy while working toward guard opening

Prerequisites

  • Understanding of guard breaking mechanics
  • Posture control fundamentals
  • Defensive framing awareness
  • Recognition of submission threats
  • Energy management abilities

State Invariants

  • Bottom player’s legs wrapped around top player’s waist
  • Bottom player’s ankles crossed/locked
  • Top player inside bottom player’s guard
  • Body connection between practitioners
  • Dynamic engagement with opponent’s upper body

Defensive Responses (When Opponent Has This State)

Offensive Transitions (Available From This State)

Counter Transitions

Expert Insights

  • Danaher System: Emphasizes systematic approaches to guard breaking that involve creating dilemmas for the bottom player rather than forcing a single technique. Focuses on proper posture maintenance and precise mechanical details in guard opening sequences, viewing the closed guard as a position to be methodically addressed through specific technical progressions.
  • Gordon Ryan: Takes a pressure-oriented approach to the closed guard, focusing on establishing strong upper body control before attempting to open the guard. Emphasizes creating pressure that forces the bottom player to compromise their ideal positioning, setting up effective guard breaks that allow transition to his preferred passing systems.
  • Eddie Bravo: Has developed specialized approaches to breaking and passing the closed guard in his 10th Planet system, often using unique pressure distributions and posture variations that differ from traditional methods. Particularly emphasizes defensive awareness against common submission threats while working to open the guard.

Common Errors

  • Error: Poor posture
    • Consequence: Leads to submission vulnerability, making it easier for the bottom player to break your posture and set up attacks like triangles or armbars.
    • Correction: Maintain a strong, upright posture with your head up and elbows in, using your hands to control their hips or break their grips.
  • Error: Neglecting grip fighting
    • Consequence: Results in loss of control, allowing the bottom player to establish dominant grips and initiate sweeps or submissions.
    • Correction: Actively engage in grip fighting, focusing on breaking their collar or wrist grips while establishing your own to limit their offense.
  • Error: Overcommitting to single break attempts
    • Consequence: Causes energy inefficiency, draining your stamina as you force a single guard break technique without adapting to their resistance.
    • Correction: Use a systematic approach, alternating between different guard break techniques to create dilemmas and conserve energy.
  • Error: Passive positioning
    • Consequence: Leads to extended time in a disadvantageous position, increasing the risk of being swept or submitted by the bottom player.
    • Correction: Stay active with constant pressure and movement, working to open the guard or transition to a more favorable position.
  • Error: Telegraphing guard opening intent
    • Consequence: Allows defensive adaptation by the bottom player, who can counter your predictable moves with prepared defenses or attacks.
    • Correction: Vary your guard breaking attempts and maintain subtle movements to avoid signaling your intentions, keeping the opponent guessing.

Training Drills

  • Posture Maintenance: Practice posture maintenance against progressive resistance, focusing on keeping your head up and elbows in to prevent submissions.
  • Guard Break Sequences: Drill guard break sequences with technical precision, working on various techniques like standing breaks or knee pins.
  • Defensive Framing: Work on defensive framing against common submissions, learning to position your arms and body to block triangles and armbars.
  • Grip Fighting Progressions: Practice grip fighting progressions from closed guard, focusing on breaking opponent’s grips and establishing your own.
  • Energy Management: Engage in energy management exercises for sustained breaking efforts, learning to balance pressure with conservation of stamina.

Decision Tree

If opponent establishes strong collar grips:

Else if opponent attempts to break posture:

Else if opponent elevates hips for sweep:

Else if opponent maintains neutral closed guard:

Position Metrics

  • Position Retention Rate: Beginner 40%, Intermediate 50%, Advanced 60%
  • Advancement Probability: Beginner 35%, Intermediate 50%, Advanced 65%
  • Submission Vulnerability: Beginner 40%, Intermediate 30%, Advanced 20%
  • Sweep Vulnerability: Beginner 45%, Intermediate 35%, Advanced 25%
  • Average Time in Position: 45-120 seconds

Optimal Paths

Standard guard opening path: Closed Guard Top → Standing Guard Break → Open Guard Top → Headquarters Position → Knee Cut Pass → Side Control

Combat base transition path: Closed Guard Top → Knee Pin Break → Combat Base → Leg Drag Setup → Leg Drag Pass → Side Control

Pressure passing path: Closed Guard Top → Stack Break → Stacking Position → Pressure Pass Setup → Double Under Pass → Side Control

Alternative passing path: Closed Guard Top → Log Splitter Break → Open Guard Top → Pressure Pass Setup → Smash Pass → Side Control

Computer Science Analogy

The Closed Guard Top represents a “constrained state” in the BJJ state machine where action space is limited by the opponent’s control mechanisms. This creates a scenario similar to a “local minimum” in optimization problems, where the player must execute precise escape algorithms to transition to a more favorable region of the state space. The position requires implementing systematic search techniques to find viable transitions (guard breaks) that minimize risk while maximizing the probability of reaching advantageous states.

Graph View

Backlinks