BJJ Graph

Knee Shield Half Guard Bottom

Dec 09, 202515 min read

Knee Shield Half Guard Bottom is one of the most fundamental and effective defensive half guard positions in modern Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu. The position is characterized by the bottom practitioner using their top leg as a structural barrier (knee shield) pressed against the opponent’s torso, creating critical distance and preventing the crushing pressure typical of flattened half guard positions. This knee shield creates a powerful frame that not only prevents the pass but also serves as a launching point for sweeps, back takes, and transitions to other guard systems. The position represents a perfect blend of defensive security and offensive potential, making it essential knowledge for practitioners at all levels.

Unlike traditional half guard where the top player can establish heavy crossface and underhook control, the knee shield creates a fundamental structural problem for the passer. The bottom player’s shin becomes a rigid barrier that prevents the top player from settling their weight and advancing their position. This distance allows the bottom player to work their grips, create angles, and maintain the mobility necessary for effective guard retention. The position is particularly effective in both gi and no-gi contexts, though grip fighting strategies differ significantly between the two.

The knee shield half guard has become a cornerstone position in modern competitive BJJ, with world-class competitors like Lucas Leite, Bernardo Faria, and Craig Jones demonstrating its effectiveness at the highest levels. The position offers multiple pathways to success: maintaining retention against pressure passers, sweeping aggressive opponents, or transitioning to more offensive guard systems when opportunities arise. Understanding the knee shield is essential for developing a complete defensive guard game.

Position Definition

  • Bottom player’s shin is pressed horizontally across opponent’s torso/chest, creating a rigid barrier that prevents forward pressure and maintains critical distance between bodies
  • Bottom player’s trapped leg remains positioned between opponent’s legs in traditional half guard configuration, with the foot typically hooking behind opponent’s far leg for additional control
  • Bottom player maintains at least one grip on opponent’s sleeve, collar, or body, preventing them from controlling both arms and establishing dominant grips for passing sequences
  • Bottom player’s hips remain mobile and not flattened to the mat, maintaining the ability to create angles, adjust the knee shield height, and generate movement for defensive and offensive purposes

Prerequisites

  • One leg trapped between opponent’s legs in half guard configuration
  • Ability to create sufficient space to insert knee shield barrier
  • Opponent attempting to pass or establish control from top half guard
  • Bottom player’s hips not completely flattened to mat
  • Sufficient frame strength to maintain knee shield under pressure

Key Defensive Principles

  • Maintain constant pressure outward with knee shield to create maximum distance and prevent opponent from settling weight
  • Keep hips mobile and ready to adjust angles—never allow hips to become completely flat or static against the mat
  • Control at least one of opponent’s arms through grips to prevent them from establishing dominant passing grips
  • Use bottom leg actively to control opponent’s posture and prevent them from standing or creating advantageous passing angles
  • Adjust knee shield height based on opponent’s pressure—higher against standing passes, lower against knee slice attempts
  • Combine frames with hip movement to create angles for sweeps and prevent opponent from consolidating position
  • Maintain ready position for quick transitions to deep half, x-guard, or other guard systems when opportunities present

Available Escapes

Old School Sweep → Mount

Success Rates:

  • Beginner: 35%
  • Intermediate: 50%
  • Advanced: 65%

Underhook Sweep from Half → Mount

Success Rates:

  • Beginner: 30%
  • Intermediate: 45%
  • Advanced: 60%

Deep Half Entry → Deep Half Guard

Success Rates:

  • Beginner: 40%
  • Intermediate: 55%
  • Advanced: 70%

Back Take Generic → Back Control

Success Rates:

  • Beginner: 25%
  • Intermediate: 40%
  • Advanced: 55%

X-Guard Sweep → X-Guard

Success Rates:

  • Beginner: 30%
  • Intermediate: 45%
  • Advanced: 60%

Lumberjack Sweep → Mount

Success Rates:

  • Beginner: 28%
  • Intermediate: 42%
  • Advanced: 58%

Kimura from Half Guard → Kimura Control

Success Rates:

  • Beginner: 20%
  • Intermediate: 35%
  • Advanced: 50%

Opponent Counters

Counter-Attacks

Decision Making from This Position

If opponent attempts to smash knee shield down and flatten position with heavy pressure:

If opponent stands up to create passing angles or attempt standing passes:

If opponent commits to knee slice or attempts to step over knee shield:

If opponent establishes underhook and attempts to consolidate position:

Common Defensive Mistakes

1. Allowing knee shield to collapse toward chest, reducing structural barrier

  • ❌ Consequence: Opponent can flatten position, establish crushing pressure, and advance to side control or mount
  • ✅ Correction: Maintain active outward pressure with knee shield, keeping shin parallel to mat and constantly pushing opponent away from centerline

2. Failing to control opponent’s arms through grips, allowing them freedom of movement

  • ❌ Consequence: Opponent can establish dominant grips like crossface and underhook, making passes significantly easier and limiting sweep options
  • ✅ Correction: Immediately establish sleeve, collar, or wrist control to prevent opponent from achieving advantageous grip configurations

3. Keeping hips completely static and flat against mat without angle adjustment

  • ❌ Consequence: Position becomes purely defensive with limited sweep opportunities, opponent can methodically work passing sequences without fear of counters
  • ✅ Correction: Constantly adjust hip angles, create micro-movements, and maintain readiness to create sweeping angles or transition opportunities

4. Positioning knee shield too high or too low for opponent’s passing strategy

  • ❌ Consequence: Shield becomes ineffective—too high allows knee slice, too low allows opponent to step over and establish mount pressure
  • ✅ Correction: Dynamically adjust knee shield height based on opponent’s passing approach—mid-chest against knee cuts, higher against pressure, lower against standing passes

5. Neglecting bottom leg control and hook maintenance on opponent’s far leg

  • ❌ Consequence: Opponent can easily extract their trapped leg, complete the pass to side control or establish dominant positions
  • ✅ Correction: Maintain active bottom leg hook behind opponent’s far leg, using it to control their posture and prevent leg extraction

6. Overcommitting to sweeps without proper setup or timing recognition

  • ❌ Consequence: Failed sweep attempts deplete energy, create passing opportunities for opponent, and can result in worse positions like mounted position
  • ✅ Correction: Develop patience in knee shield, wait for opponent’s weight commitment or errors before attempting sweeps, maintain position security first

Training Drills for Defense

Knee Shield Retention Against Progressive Pressure

Partner applies increasing pressure attempting to flatten knee shield. Practitioner maintains frames, adjusts angles, and uses hip movement to prevent collapse. Start at 50% pressure, increase to 100% over 5-minute rounds. Focus on maintaining structural integrity of knee shield under maximum pressure.

Duration: 5 minutes per round, 3 rounds

Grip Fighting Flow from Knee Shield

Both practitioners work for dominant grips from knee shield half guard. Top player seeks crossface and underhook, bottom player prevents these while establishing sleeve/collar control. Reset when dominant position achieved. Develops grip awareness and hand fighting essential for position maintenance.

Duration: 3 minutes per round, 4 rounds

Sweep Timing Recognition Drill

Top player alternates between different passing strategies (smash, knee slice, standing). Bottom player must recognize timing windows and execute appropriate sweep. Coach calls out passing type, practitioner responds with correct sweep option. Builds decision-making speed and sweep selection.

Duration: 2 minutes per scenario, 6 scenarios

Transition Chain Drilling

From knee shield, practice flowing between deep half, x-guard, and standard half guard based on opponent’s reactions. Partner provides moderate resistance and varies responses. Focus on seamless transitions maintaining control throughout movement sequences.

Duration: 4 minutes continuous flow, 3 rounds

Escape and Survival Paths

Kimura submission path from underhook battle

Knee Shield Half Guard Bottom → Kimura from Half Guard → Kimura Control → Kimura

Back attack path via old school sweep

Knee Shield Half Guard Bottom → Old School Sweep → Back Control → Rear Naked Choke

Deep half to leg lock progression

Knee Shield Half Guard Bottom → Deep Half Entry → Deep Half Guard → Inside Ashi-Garami → Heel Hook

X-guard to mounted attack sequence

Knee Shield Half Guard Bottom → X-Guard Sweep → X-Guard → Mount → Armbar from Mount

Success Rates and Statistics

Skill LevelRetention RateAdvancement ProbabilitySubmission Probability
Beginner50%25%10%
Intermediate65%40%20%
Advanced80%55%35%

Average Time in Position: 1-3 minutes depending on skill differential and passing strategy

Expert Analysis

John Danaher

The knee shield half guard represents a fundamental application of structural mechanics in guard retention. The shin creates what I call a ‘distance management system’—it’s not merely a passive barrier but an active tool for controlling the spatial relationship between you and your opponent. The critical insight is that the knee shield must be combined with upper body frames and hip mobility to create a complete defensive system. Many practitioners make the error of relying solely on the knee shield itself, but this is insufficient against skilled passers. You must understand that the knee shield’s effectiveness is predicated on maintaining proper distance—too close and it collapses, too far and you lose control. The position demands constant micro-adjustments in shield height and angle based on opponent pressure vectors. From an offensive perspective, the knee shield creates the distance necessary for sweep mechanics to function—you cannot generate effective sweeping leverage when flattened. The underhook becomes exponentially more powerful when combined with the distance created by the shield, allowing you to control opponent posture and create the angles necessary for high-percentage sweeps.

Gordon Ryan

Knee shield half guard is absolutely essential in modern competitive grappling, and I use it extensively in my own game when playing bottom position. The reality is that against high-level competitors, you cannot afford to get flattened in half guard—once they establish the crossface and flatten you out, you’re in survival mode and the pass is inevitable. The knee shield prevents this from happening and keeps you in the fight. My approach is aggressive—I’m not just maintaining the shield defensively, I’m constantly threatening the old school sweep and back takes to keep my opponent honest. If they respect the sweep threat, they can’t commit fully to the pass. If they ignore it, I take their back or sweep them. The key detail most people miss is the grip fighting—you absolutely must control their sleeves or collar to prevent them from getting the underhook and crossface combination. Once they get both grips, even the best knee shield won’t save you. I also use the position as a gateway to my leg lock game—when opponents stand to pass the knee shield, that’s my entry to outside ashi and saddle positions. The knee shield creates the distance I need to enter leg entanglements safely.

Eddie Bravo

The knee shield is fundamental to the 10th Planet system, and we’ve developed it into something much more dynamic than the traditional approach. We call it the ‘electric fence’ because it’s not just a static barrier—it’s an active threat that’s constantly electrifying the position with sweep and transition possibilities. In no-gi especially, the knee shield is your lifeline because you don’t have collar grips to maintain distance. What makes our approach different is we’re always looking to combine the knee shield with lockdown control or transition to electric chair and other 10th Planet positions. The moment someone tries to smash through the shield, we’re going deep half or transitioning to the truck position. We’ve also developed specific setups for the vaporizer and other leg attacks from the knee shield that most people don’t see coming. The shield creates the perfect angle for these attacks because your opponent is focused on passing and doesn’t recognize the submission threats. Another thing we emphasize is using the shield to create the whip-up motion—you’re not just blocking with the knee, you’re using it to off-balance and create sweeping momentum. When you combine the shield with strategic lockdown moments, you create a system where the opponent can never settle and establish their pressure game.